Childhood emotional neglect gets called the invisible trauma. The trauma of what didn't happen. The comfort you never got.
I get why. But I think we've got it all wrong, because something always did happen. Someone rolled their eyes. Someone told you to stop being so ridiculous.
In this episode I'm digging into why describing emotional neglect only as an absence makes it harder to recognise in your own childhood, and harder to heal from.
Spoiler: neglect isn't invisible. We've just been describing it in a way that makes it harder to see.
If you've spent years trying to make sense of your childhood and the reparenting advice hasn't quite landed, pull up a chair.
-
Childhood emotional neglect, why we've got it all wrong
Neglect is not invisible. We're just describing it in a way that makes it harder to see, and I think we can do way better than that.
Why childhood emotional neglect gets called "the invisible trauma"
What if the way we've been talking about childhood emotional neglect is actually making it harder for people to understand what actually happened to them? And what if that is then influencing what you think you need to do to recover?
Because there's this really popular idea that emotional neglect gets called the invisible trauma. The trauma of what didn't happen. The comfort you did not receive, the emotional support you did not get, the nurturance that was missing.
And while I do understand that framing, I think it's helpful, I've got a bit of a problem with it, which is, I will admit, becoming a bit of a theme in my podcast. Apparently, I've got a problem with everything. But seriously, I think this way of understanding neglect can be quite misleading, because when we describe neglect primarily in terms of what didn't happen, I think we risk overlooking something very important.
What actually did happen? Like, what happened instead? And I think this is extremely important, not just for how we understand our childhoods, but also for what we think we need to do to recover.
What actually happens to a child
Let me show you what I mean, because I think this becomes really obvious when we look at what actually happens to a child. So let me set the scene. You're five years old, you're playing outside, and a big dog comes roaring into your backyard. It's barking, foaming at the mouth, charging towards you, and the owner only just manages to grab it before it reaches you.
So obviously, you're terrified. You run inside, you're crying and you're shaking, and you run to mum. (If you're listening on the podcast, quickly go on YouTube and see my face, because I need you to look at my facial expression.)
You run inside, you're crying, you're shaking, you run to mum, and she looks at you and says, "Don't be so ridiculous. You're fine. What are you carrying on about?"
So we could describe that experience as a moment where your mum did not meet your needs. We could say that what happened was that you didn't receive the comfort, reassurance and emotional support you needed, which is true, you didn't. But here is my question: is that really the most important thing that happened in that moment?
Because something else happened, didn't it? You were frightened, you went to mum for comfort, and rather than getting comfort and safety, you were met with criticism and dismissal, and your distress was actually kind of mocked. "You're being ridiculous."
So therein lies my thesis. That happened. I find it very interesting that we take experiences like this and describe them primarily in terms of what was missing. Because sure, the comfort was absent. But your mum's response wasn't. Knowing what actually happened gives us something much more specific to work with and focus on.
And it also raises the question: why are we describing experiences like this primarily in terms of what didn't happen, when there was clearly something that did?
What is emotional neglect? Acts of commission vs omission
Now, before anybody gets upset with me (people get angry on the internet no matter what), I'm not saying there's anything wrong with recognising neglect as something that was missing, because that is actually true as well.
Both things are true. And I think that idea has been very important, because when people think about childhood trauma, they often think about more stereotypical events, such as violence or sexual abuse, threats, humiliation. Things that happened that shouldn't have happened. Emotional neglect, on the other hand, is often understood in terms of things that should have happened but did not.
This is in the trauma world, so don't worry about this too much if it's confusing, but I'll mention it because it's true. It's sometimes described as the distinction between acts of commission (the things that went wrong, the things that happened that should not have happened) and acts of omission, where something that should have happened, like my needs getting met, did not.
And I do get why that's useful. Because if you grew up in a family where nobody hit you, nobody screamed at you, nothing on the outside, a lay person would look at your childhood and go, "Nothing that dramatic happened." You might look back and think, "I just had a normal childhood. Nothing happened."
This is why it gets called the invisible trauma. It's easy to miss if you don't have a trained eye. I find a lot of trauma therapists also miss this, and it is hard. It can be very hard to detect. When we look back, if you don't have that understanding and that eye, you're not going to register that anything went wrong. It's quite subtle.
So people in this situation may look back and say, "Yeah, I had a perfectly normal childhood," even if their emotional needs were constantly dismissed or overlooked. They might not recognise there was a problem because they never experienced anything different. They don't know what was missing. They have no reference point.
So providing a framework for recognising the absence of something is valuable. I totally get that. What I'm questioning is whether describing neglect primarily as an absence gives us a sufficiently complete picture of someone's experience.
"Well, what did happen?"
Because when someone says, "I wasn't comforted when I was upset," my next question is, "Well, what did happen? When you were upset, what happened? You're telling me what was missing, which is fine. It's helpful to know something was missing. But what actually happened? Did you go to mum crying and get ignored? Did she roll her eyes at you? Did your dad tell you to stop being so ridiculous? Were you mocked? Were you dismissed? Were you rejected? Or were you just left alone because nobody was checking on you? Did they even notice?"
Those are different experiences, and I think this really matters. Because the fact that comfort was missing is a theme across all of those. It tells us what didn't happen. It doesn't tell us what happened. Comfort was missing in all of those situations, but they are very different problems.
And here's where I think this whole distinction between acts of commission and acts of omission actually falls apart. Because when we look at emotional neglect, yeah, sure, it's an absence of something, but it's actually more like acts of rejection. I got ignored, I got rejected, I got dismissed, whatever happened.
I think the line between what is absent and what actually happened doesn't make any sense, because the other side of omission is always something that happened. If there was something missing, something also had to happen to cause it to be missing, right? That makes sense in my mind.
Am I missing something? Because it doesn't make any sense to me. All of these experiences are something that happened that shouldn't have. I shouldn't have been rejected. I shouldn't have been ignored. I shouldn't have been dismissed. I shouldn't have been humiliated or shamed.
When your parents got it right sometimes
And so I think that's another problem with this way of describing neglect, because what happens when your parents actually did give you those things sometimes? I don't think this gets enough attention, because most parents are not consistently neglectful. Some are. Some are neglectful more often than they get it right. But most parents who fall into this category will be emotionally responsive sometimes, and dismissing or invalidating at other times.
The problem is that if there hasn't been consistent neglect, a person who reads about this absence of something isn't going to see themselves in that. Let me explain that a little more clearly. Say your parent was emotionally responsive sometimes, but they were inconsistent, and you were neglected, dismissed, ignored or rejected enough for it to cause you a problem. But they got it right sometimes.
I think you're going to read about childhood emotional neglect and come across descriptions like, "You lacked emotional support. Your parents were not there for you. Your emotional needs were consistently unmet." And you're probably going to say, "Well, that's not completely right. That doesn't quite fit. Sometimes Mum was really supportive. Sometimes Dad could be loving. I did get it sometimes."
And you're right, you did, sometimes. But you were also probably repeatedly dismissed, criticised and rejected, and those experiences are often impactful, even though your parents were capable of being supportive and responsive at other times.
This is where the language of what was missing also becomes problematic. Because if you fit into that category, you're probably not going to fully identify with the idea of emotional neglect, because you're going to remember receiving the things that we are telling you must have been absent for you to fit this category.
Healing from childhood emotional neglect: why the framing matters
And this brings me to my most important point of all. How we describe a problem, how we understand a problem, changes what we think will fix it.
The diagnosis impacts the solution. The way we think about a problem influences what we think we need to do about it. If we have the wrong problem, we're going to have the wrong solution. And I think emotional neglect is a really interesting example of that, because we understand the problem primarily as something that was missing.
So what does that suggest the solution might be? First of all, it's very vague, but it sounds like we need to provide what wasn't there. If you didn't receive comfort, you need to learn to comfort yourself. If your emotions weren't validated, you need to learn to validate your emotions. If you didn't get adequate nurturance, you need to learn to nurture yourself.
This is where a lot of the advice around reparenting yourself, caring for your inner child and giving yourself the love you didn't receive comes from. And those are good things. I'm not saying they're bad. Far from it. Being able to comfort yourself, validate your emotions and respond to your needs with compassion are very important skills, very important for healthy wellbeing.
But I think there's an assumption worth questioning here. If the problem is conceptualised as something missing, does providing what was missing now necessarily address the effect of what happened?
What EMDR shows us
There's something about how we work with memories in EMDR that I think demonstrates exactly why this distinction matters. In EMDR we work with specific memories. And when we're identifying a memory to process, one of the things we ask is, what image represents the worst part of the experience?
Now think back to the five-year-old. The child runs inside terrified, looking for comfort, and mum turns around and says, "Don't be so ridiculous. You're fine." If we're describing that experience in terms of emotional neglect, obviously we're going to say the child didn't receive the reassurance and comfort they needed.
But imagine that person is sitting in front of me 20 years later, recalling this experience. And I say, "When you think about the memory, what is the most disturbing part of it to you right now?" What do you think they're going to identify? I'll tell you exactly what they're going to identify. Mum's face. The moment she reacted. The look on her face, the look of disapproval, the tone in her voice, the anger, the contempt, the judgement. The moment she reacted with that energy of rejection, and "you are not okay, this is not okay."
So you hear that and tell me that emotional neglect is invisible. You tell me this is the trauma of what didn't happen. Like I said, I get why people describe it that way, and I think recognising what we didn't get is still important. It can be very helpful for people making sense of their childhoods when nothing obviously terrible happened.
In saying that though, when I just talked out that scene of mum's face, that is something terrible. It is. My stomach turned saying it out loud and just visualising that scene. It's not that it wasn't obviously terrible. I think it's just that we haven't learned how to look for this properly, because we've been thinking about it as something that is missing.
Childhood emotional neglect is not invisible
And I'm not suggesting we abandon that understanding, but I am suggesting that I don't think it's enough. Not by a long shot. Because in my opinion, what we are calling an invisible trauma involves very visible experiences of being ignored, dismissed, criticised, rejected, et cetera, et cetera. These are clear events that happened.
So if you've spent years trying to understand or recover from childhood emotional neglect, and there are things that still haven't changed in the ways you had expected, I think this is worth thinking more about. Because perhaps the question isn't just, what didn't I get? But also, what actually happened?
Because knowing you weren't comforted tells us one thing. But knowing that you were repeatedly ignored or mocked or dismissed tells us something so much more specific, and so much more workable, especially therapeutically. It gives us a much better idea of what went wrong and what might need to change.
Okay, so my thesis for this episode: neglect is not invisible. We're just describing it in a way that makes it harder to see, and I think we can do way better than that.
So I hope you found this helpful. Please subscribe, leave a review, literally anything to help tell the algorithm gods that my stuff is good. Again, thank you so much for listening. Stay tuned for next time. Banger after banger over here, and I look forward to seeing you then. Bye.
Childhood emotional neglect: your questions answered
-
Childhood emotional neglect is usually described as what didn't happen: the comfort, emotional support and nurturance you didn't receive. That's true, but it's only half the picture. Something always did happen instead. You were dismissed, criticised, ignored, mocked or rejected, and those experiences matter just as much.
-
Because from the outside, nothing dramatic happened. Nobody hit you, nobody screamed at you, so it's easy to look back and think you had a normal childhood. Without a reference point for what was missing, it can be very hard to recognise.
-
Yes. Most parents aren't consistently neglectful. Many are emotionally responsive sometimes and dismissing or invalidating at other times. If you were repeatedly dismissed or criticised, that can still have a real impact, even if your parents got it right some of the time.
-
Learning to comfort yourself, validate your emotions and respond to your needs with compassion are important skills. But if neglect is only understood as something missing, giving yourself what was missing now may not address the effect of what actually happened. Knowing specifically what happened gives you much more to work with.
-
EMDR works with specific memories. When someone recalls a neglect memory, the most disturbing part is rarely the comfort they didn't get. It's usually what happened: a parent's face, their tone, the disapproval or contempt. That's something concrete that can be processed.